Windows 365, A successor to Azure Virtual Desktop?
Spread the love

Azure Virtual Desktop (referred as AVD hereafter) is already doing wonders and thousands (if not millions) of customers have already adopted the technology, around the globe.

Following Social Media Conversation Vendors chart (Gartner) shows the increasing interest and market-penetration:

Gartner’s Market Guide for Desktop as a Service gives us some interesting insights and predictions relevant to this topic:

  • Desktop as a service (DaaS) market revenue grew by 98% in 2020 compared to 2019, and it is forecast to grow by 68% in 2021 as I&O leaders enable use cases including secure home working.
  • “By 2024, 80% of all virtual desktops served to remote users will be DaaS up from fewer than 30% today.
  • Market attention has increasingly focused on Microsoft Azure-hosted DaaS solutions due to proximity with Microsoft 365 data and license requirements.

On July 14, 2021 Microsoft announced addition of a new member “Windows 365” to its “365” family (read more about the announcement here) which became general availability on August 02, 2021 (read Scott Manchester‘s GA announcement here).

Considering Microsoft loves changing the product/technology names and acronyms frequently (as Microsoft recently changed the name of Windows Virtual Desktop to Azure Virtual Desktop (blog post here)), I was curious to know if “Windows 365” was a new name of Azure Virtual Desktop, or a modern version of AVD or if it is something new, in parallel?

The phobia and a need-of-the-time to remain updated, before your customer does, lead me directly into the research.

Off-the-tangent: The name-changing practice of Microsoft has various benefits as well such as it naturally gives you a feel that product is new/modern, it automatically makes the previous version to be referred as “legacy” and create a mindset to eventually move to latest name/version. Basically it keeps the momentum going on!!

Microsoft has hundreds of experts and spends billions of dollars on marketing strategies. This technique seems to be a good one. (despite the fact, it keeps us awake in nights).

What will be covered in this post

With this post, I am trying to share the understanding in a simplified manner. Hope it saves you some time from wandering across multiple internet resources!!

This blog post will cover:

  1. Develop an understanding of What Windows 365 is?
  2. How it is similar and different than Azure Virtual Desktop?
  3. Use cases to best utilize it.

What is Windows 365?

So first thing to establish is, Windows 365 is NOT the successor or alternative of Azure Virtual Desktop. Instead, it is a new offering which leverages the Azure Virtual Desktop on the backend and then adds a (Microsoft managed) management layer on top.

Windows 365 leveraging Azure Virtual Desktop Infrastructure on backend

It can be utilized along side with Azure Virtual Desktop (depending on different use-cases, user profile requirements and/or compute requirements such as GPU VMs which are not available on Windows 365 at the time of writing this blog. Roadmap for in-development features can be found here.) to form the best and cost-effective desktop-as-a-service and cloud pc combination.

Diagram courtesy to Nerdio

The most prominent purpose of bringing Windows 365 into the market, is to remove the following challenges which are associated to Azure Virtual Desktop (AVD):

  1. Unpredictable Azure consumption (since AVD offers PAYG and multi-session instances).
  2. The complexity of sizing/profiling

Windows 365 provides a fixed monthly price (OPEX) for a dedicated cloud pc for individuals. Hence it makes the recurring cost predictable, for organizations.

Microsoft made this possible by offering “Windows 365” as a plan under Office 365. Hence it is tightly integrated with Zero-Trust model which increases security assurances for your critical business assets.

Similar to Azure Virtual Desktop, Windows 365 natively integrates with Microsoft Cloud Services to provide unified governance and management.

Microsoft introduce Windows 365 as “Cloud PC” (here) and describe it as “Securely stream your Windows experience—including your personalized apps, content, and settings—from the Microsoft cloud to any device with your Windows 365 Cloud PC”.

Let’s break this statement into simple blocks to develop a good understanding of the offering:

Cloud PC

A “Cloud PC” is a multi-purpose computer running on cloud, meant for a single licensed user. Imagine your desktop being virtualized and hosted as well as managed by Microsoft while you connect to it and enjoy it as a service.

Securely Stream your Windows Experience (Apps, Content and Settings)

Windows 365 is a Microsoft-managed cloud service. It allows you to securely stream/access your desktop, applications and user profile (contents and settings) with your personalized experience, from any where and from (almost) any device.

It allows all those enterprise fancy features like domain join, group policies, integration with Microsoft 365 cloud services such as Microsoft 365 Apps, Endpoint Manager and lot more.

Since Windows 365 is a Microsoft-managed Azure service, organizations do not get direct full admin access by default. and need to manage it via Microsoft Endpoint Manager Portal.

Windows 365 Flavors (Editions)

Windows 365 comes in two flavors: Business and Enterprise, each with different fixed desktop sizes. Following Windows 365 plans comparison page (taken from here) show the primary offering difference:

Windows 365 Plans comparison

Comparison: Windows 365 vs. Azure Virtual Desktop

Windows 365 is an evolving technology hence the similarities and differences may vary over time. However at the time of writing this blog, following is how it looks like:

Management and Operations

FeatureWindows 365
Enterprise
Windows 365
Business
Azure Virtual Desktop
(Personal)
Azure Virtual Desktop
(Pooled)
Management PortalMicrosoft Endpoint ManagerNo admin portal
(Microsoft managed)
Microsoft Azure Portal Microsoft Azure Portal
Operating SystemWindows 10 or 11 Enterprise
(single session)
Windows 10 or 11 Enterprise
(single session)
Windows 10 or 11 Enterprise
(single session), Windows Server
Windows 10 or 11 Enterprise
(single session or multi-session),
Windows Server
Desktop Images ManagementCustom and Microsoft-provided.

No image based management
due to persistent VMs.
Microsoft-provided onlyCustom and Microsoft-provided.

Image based management
(with FSLogix).
Custom and Microsoft-provided.

Image based management.
Applications
and Update
Manual install or
Delivered via MEM
Manual install onlyDelivered via MEM,
image updates
or MSIX app attach
Delivered via MEM,
image updates
or MSIX app attach
Hyper-Visor level Backup Not possibleNot possiblePossible Possible
Hypervisor level DRNot possibleNot possiblePossiblePossible
MonitoringEndpoint Analytics
(Defender)
Not AvailableAzure Monitor / Defender Azure Monitor / Defender
User ProfilesStored locally on C driveStored locally on C drive Stored locally on C drive
or
FSLogix stored on SMB share
FSLogix stored on Azure Files
or Azure NetApp Files
or File Server VM
NetworkingFlexible customer managed
(Connect to your own VNET)
Not configurable
(Microsoft managed)
Flexible & Customer Managed Flexible & Customer Managed
Auto-ScalingNot applicable.
Fixed monthly cost
Not applicable.
Fixed monthly cost
Flexible
Variable cost as per usage or auto-scaled sizing
Flexible
Variable cost as per usage or auto-scaled sizing (cost saving)
Table: Management and Operations

End User Experience

FeatureWindows 365
Enterprise
Windows 365
Business
Azure Virtual Desktop
(Personal)
Azure Virtual Desktop
(Pooled)
End-user
Connectivity
Web: HTML-5 (browsers)
Clients: Windows, Mac
Mobile: iOS, Android
Thin clients: (approved clients)
Web: HTML-5 (browsers)
Clients: Windows, Mac
Mobile: iOS, Android
Thin clients: (approved clients)
Web: HTML-5 (browsers)
Clients: Windows, Mac
Mobile: iOS, Android
Thin clients: (approved clients)
Web: HTML-5 (browsers)
Clients: Windows, Mac
Mobile: iOS, Android
Thin clients: (approved clients)
Web URLhttps://windows365.microsoft.comSame as W365 Enterprisehttps://rdweb.wvd.microsoft.com/arm/webclientSame as AVD personal
Printing and ScanningRedirection using client,
Universal printing &
network based printing
Redirection using client Redirection using client,
Universal printing &
network based printing
Redirection using client,
Universal printing &
network based printing
Com port forwarding Supported Not supportedSupported Supported
Self-Service
(restart from portal)
Yes, from web portal Yes, from web portalNot available nativelyNot available natively
Table: End user experience

Licensing and Infrastructure

Cost ComponentsWindows 365
Enterprise
Windows 365
Business
Azure Virtual Desktop
(Personal)
Azure Virtual Desktop
(Pooled)
Cloud PC
(CPU and Memory)
Based on Windows 365 cloud pc license plan
(fixed recurring)

price depends on edition
& cloud-pc size
(mentioned above)
Based on Windows 365 cloud pc license plan
(fixed recurring)

price depends on edition
& cloud-pc size
(mentioned above)
Based on Azure consumption^
(fixed recurring)
Based on Azure consumption^
(variable recurring)
Operating SystemWindows 10 or 11 Enterprise license
[buy standalone Windows plan or
cover under M365 suite]
Windows 10 or 11 Enterprise license
[buy standalone Windows plan or
cover under M365 suite]
Windows 10 or 11 Enterprise license
[buy standalone Windows plan or
cover under M365 suite]
Windows 10 or 11 Enterprise license
[buy standalone Windows plan or
cover under M365 suite]
NetworkingBased on Azure Consumption
(connect to your Azure VNET)
Included in above Cloud PC compute price Based on Azure Consumption^ Based on Azure Consumption^
InternetBased on Azure Consumption
(Internet Egress Costs)
Included in above Cloud PC compute price (with reasonable limits around bandwidth) Based on Azure Consumption
(Internet Egress Costs)
Based on Azure Consumption
(Internet Egress Costs)
ManagementMicrosoft Endpoint Manager
subscription
(mandatory)
Cloud-PC management portal
+
Microsoft Endpoint Manager subscription
(optional)
Azure portal
+
Microsoft Endpoint Manager
subscription
(optional)
Azure portal
+
Microsoft Endpoint Manager
subscription
(optional)
Office AppMicrosoft Office 365 subscription Microsoft Office 365 subscription Microsoft Office 365 subscription with SCA rightsMicrosoft Office 365 subscription with SCA rights
Optional ComponentsAdditional Azure Consumption may be required depending on scenarios such as:

Extend connectivity to on-prem
network security solutions i.e. Azure Firewall or marketplace
Image Management solutions etc.
Not Applicable Additional Azure Consumption^ may be required depending on scenarios such as:

Extend connectivity to on-prem (VPN)
network security solutions (i.e. Azure Firewall or marketplace)

Image Management solutions
User profile storage solution etc.
Hypervisor Backup and DR
Hypervisor Monitoring
Additional Azure Consumption^ may be required depending on scenarios such as:

Extend connectivity to on-prem (VPN)
network security solutions (i.e. Azure Firewall or marketplace)

Image Management solutions
User profile storage solution etc.
Hypervisor Backup and DR Hypervisor Monitoring
Table: Licensing and Infrastructure

^ use Azure pricing calculator for estimation

Responsibility

Following matrix highlight the shared-responsibility difference between AVD and Windows 365.

Shared Responsibility Matrix

For more granular differences between Windows 365 Business and Windows 365 Enterprise, refer to the Microsoft Docs link here.

Windows 365 Use Cases

Some of the prominent use-cases for Windows 365 include:

  1. Temporary Workforces: Quickly onboard and offboard the Windows 365 instances (OPEX model) for short term projects or temporary or special project requirements.
  2. Mergers and Acquisitions: Leverage Windows 365 for your growing or shrinking businesses needs.
  3. Disaster Recovery: Microsoft managed Windows 365 instances can be lifesaving in scenarios like Disaster Recovery.
  4. High Capacity Computing: Organizations can provide secure, highly available and managed Windows 365 cloud PCs to their workforce requiring high performance computing for their design / architecture / simulations needs.
  5. Data / Resources Security: Leverage managed and governed Windows 365 to access your most critical resources without worry.

Conclusion

Windows 365 is a new model of delivering PC as a cloud service to the users. It is not an alternative to Azure Virtual Desktop, instead it is optimized version of AVD built for simplicity, by compromising a bit on flexibility offered by AVD.

It is meant to provide a fixed recurring pricing model (as compared to Azure Virtual Desktop) and hence becomes a predictable cost model helpful for organizations looking for budget estimation and control. The licenses for Windows 365 appears in Office 365 portal.

It comes in two modes:

Windows 365 Business

  • Seems suitable for startups and small organizations (which do not require customization and granular control).
  • Fully managed by Microsoft. Runs on Microsoft cloud. No Azure subscription required
  • Quick provisioning (Just assign the license and Cloud PC is good to go (in an hour with a email notification)
  • Limited to 300 users maximum per organization.
  • Shared management model (Windows 365 enterprise)
  • Windows 365 Admin portal for limited management by user (no admin portal).
  • No additional investments required i.e. Intune licenses, ADDS VMs, egress traffic charges,

Windows 365 Enterprise

  • Seems suitable for medium and enterprise scale organizations (which require more granular controls and have larger user base).
  • Leverage Microsoft Endpoint Manger portal for all deployment and administration tasks (i.e. software deployment, patching and policies etc.) can be performed.
  • It has additional requirements like connecting Windows 365 Enterprise to your Azure VNET (Bring Your Own Network) for scenarios like:
    • Azure Hybrid Join
    • local DNS resolution
    • Extending connectivity to on-premise network etc.
Bring Your Own Network (BYON)
  • Requires Microsoft 365 suite (existing investments can be leveraged) for covering:
    • Administration and Management – using Microsoft Endpoint Manager subscription
    • Operating System License – using Widows 10/11 Enterprise
    • Protection using Microsoft 365 Defender for Endpoint
    • Productivity Tools using Office 365 Apps.
  • Additional cost factors to be considered such as:
    • Azure consumption for:
      • Above Azure landing zone components i.e. VNET, VPN, Azure VMs for DC, Firewall etc. (if not already in place)
      • Egress traffic charges on Azure
      • Azure Compute Gallery – if customized Windows 10/11 image to be stored and used.

Refer to Steven DeQuincey‘s blog for more guidance around various provisioning scenarios and use-cases on the article here .

Hope the article is helpful for you to understand the Windows 365 technology, its pros and cons and usage scenarios. Stay tuned for more updates on the Windows 365 and other cloud topics!!

–End of Blog —

Hi, I am Junaid Ahmed - and I am obsessed with all things cloud: infra, apps, data and AI. With an extensive background and expertise (15+ years) around Microsoft technologies, I am an expert on Microsoft cloud, hybrid and on-premises technologies. I have been enjoying consulting organizations in stepping closer to their business goals and visions. Be it digital/business transformation, or optimization, I help organizations in their journey for cloud adoption, application modernization, application enlightnement. My latest craving and enthusiasm is Data Sciences, ML and AI which is keeping me at unrest and helping me to prepare for the next big thing of my professional career. I’m always happy to connect with like-minded people, executives, cloud architects and enthusiasts. Shoot me a message – I look forward to hearing from you!

2 Thoughts on “Windows 365!! a successor to Azure Virtual Desktop?”

Comments are closed.